A Completely Different View of 401(k)s and Retirement Savings

MP900409255

“A 401(k) plan ensures that you have money to spend during your retirement years. However, there are reasons why a 401(k) stinks.”

It’s almost always enlightening to hear from a different perspective, even in finance. This article from Born2Invest, “Retirement planning: The downsides of your 401(k),” takes a somewhat contrarian view of retirement accounts in general and the use of 401(k)s in particular. We may not agree. However, it’s worth the read.

The article notes that historically, retirement as a concept is relatively new. People just worked as long as they were able to. In 1881, Otto Van Bismarck petitioned for the creation of a government system to support the elderly and the concept of a social security system was created. Their retirement age was 70—the same as life expectancy. In 1935, the American Social Security system was created. For a few generations we worked, we saved, we got pensions from employers and when we celebrated our 65th birthday, we retired.

That world has passed. The Revenue Act of 1978 created the 401(k) and defined benefit plans went away as corporations passed the burden of saving and investing for retirement to employees. There is now a huge industry of employer-sponsored, employee-funded retirement plans with assets of more than $7.7 trillion. IRAs hold more than $8.6 trillion.

Why does that stink? One of the benefits marketed by 401(k) providers is that they allow owners to defer income and taxes. However, “defer” doesn’t mean they are tax free. You’ll pay taxes when you take the money out. To be sure that you do, there are Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs). You’re taxed not just on the distributions but also on the investment gains.

The traditional thinking is that you’re going to retire, your income will decrease and so you’ll be in a lower tax bracket. But will it? If your combined income from Social Security, pensions and RMDs send you into a higher tax bracket, you may be paying more in taxes. This is especially true, if you have lost the deductions: kids growing up, no mortgage and no pre-tax contributions.

Your retirement funds are supposed to be just for retirement. However, sometimes there are bumps along the way and, if you have no other assets, that’s where you’ll go at a high price.

401(k)s have limited investment options and you’re typically limited to mutual funds and sometimes to Exchange-Traded Funds (EFTs).

Those retirement plans are not free. A 401(k) has high administrative costs and underlying investments have fund fees, based on the companies and their management activity.

Is the 401(k) the best plan for you? The article says to consider your options, so you are not just following the herd. Workplace related retirement plans could be the best option, but you should be aware of the costs, taxes and restrictions.


Reference: Born2Invest.com (Sep. 13, 2018) “Retirement planning: The downsides of your 401(k)”

Get Help from a Wisconsin Probate and Estate Planning Attorney

The estate planning lawyers of Krause Donovan Estate Law Partners, LLC practice law in the areas of Probate, Wills, Estate Planning, and Trusts. We assist clients in and around Madison, Wisconsin with all matters related to estate planning, trusts, and probate matters. Our dedicated attorneys will even make house calls if you are unable to come to our office.

To attend a free estate planning workshop or to receive our client planner to assess your estate planning mindset, contact our office by calling (608) 268-5751 or use our online contact form.