Mind the Gap: Estate Tax Cliff

pexels-photo-1028726-300x200“When the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act went into effect, many clients and advisors assumed that their days of worrying about the estate tax were largely over. Not so fast.”

The big news was that the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act doubled the federal estate tax exemption to $11.18 million per person (and $22.36 million per couple, with portability). This enormous exemption increase gave many Americans who are in the highest of all tax brackets a reason to cheer. However, in reality, few wealthy Americans ever pay the tax. However, according to “Beware the Estate Tax Cliff,” an article appearing in Wealth Management, it’s not all good news.

For one thing, such a huge increase means that many estate plans that factor in the old exemption in complex ways, have been thrown out of whack. Many wills were created before the exemption increase and some provide directions that no longer work. If the will says, “send to my credit shelter trust an amount equal to the federal exemption,” that means $11.18 million is now headed to a credit shelter trust. That might not be what the clients were expecting to happen.

It’s not hard to understand. Plans that were perfectly balanced with a $5.4 million exemption are now being upended by doubling that amount.

Let’s also not forget about state estate taxes, which is what most people do pay.

The Act has no bearing on state estate taxes. In the past few years, many states have passed laws to ensure that the state estate tax exemption matched the federal one—before it was doubled. As a result, there is now a $5 million gap between federal and state estate tax exemptions. A plan that centers totally on leveraging the new larger federal exemption, could end up exceeding that state exemption amount.

Only about 14 states implement estate taxes for deaths after Jan. 1, 2018, and the state estate tax rates are usually much lower than the 40% federal rate. However, you still need to be aware of the specific rules and exemptions that apply in your state. You don’t want your heirs to get hit with an unexpected tax bill.

If you live in New York, a word to the wise: New York is the largest state that still levys a state estate tax. Not only is there still a large gap between the New York State estate tax exemption and the federal one, but New York has an added wrinkle of applying the exemption differently.

An estate is normally taxed based on a percentage of the amount by which it exceeds the exemption. That initial exemption is almost always tax free. However, New York implements a “cliff rule,” where if an estate exceeds the exemption by more than 5%, the exemption is effectively ignored, and the entire estate gets taxed. If you’re even 5% over, you’re in for it. New York also doesn’t have portability. With a top rate of 16 percent, that’s a nasty tax surprise.

Talk with our estate planning attorneys about how the new federal exemption impacts your estate plan and whether any changes need to be made before the end of the year.


Reference: Wealth Management (Sep. 17, 2018) “Beware the Estate Tax Cliff”

Get Help from a Wisconsin Probate and Estate Planning Attorney

The estate planning lawyers of Krause Donovan Estate Law Partners, LLC practice law in the areas of Probate, Wills, Estate Planning, and Trusts. We assist clients in and around Madison, Wisconsin with all matters related to estate planning, trusts, and probate matters. Our dedicated attorneys will even make house calls if you are unable to come to our office.

To attend a free estate planning workshop or to receive our client planner to assess your estate planning mindset, contact our office by calling (608) 268-5751 or use our online contact form.